The Moment: Olenna Tyrell has the last word
Setting the Scene: After the Lannister army takes Highgarden, Jaime goes to Olenna Tyrell to deliver the queen’s justice. However, Olenna still has some final truths to tell.
Why It’s Awesome: I know many people find the battle scenes on Game of Thrones to be some of the best parts of the show, but I would trade all the cinematic battles in the world for great conversations between excellent actors. Luckily, that’s exactly what we got in “The Queen’s Justice.” There were so many fantastic monologues and dialogues in this episode that it was the hardest so far to choose my favorite moment to single out. I toyed for a long time with choosing Jon and Tyrion’s perfect reunion and subsequent discussion of brooding, and part of me wanted to discuss Lena Headey’s insane (in more ways than one) talent in Cersei’s big scene with Ellaria Sand. However, sometimes sentimentality gets the better of you, and if this is the last time I get to write about how amazing Diana Rigg has been as Olenna Tyrell and how brilliant that character is in general, then I’m going to write about it.
My favorite thing about this scene was that it was a match made in heaven between a great actor and a great reactor. No one delivers lines like Rigg, and no one reacts with the subtlety and depth of Nikolaj Coster-Waldau. Watching his expressions change as Olenna touched on some hard truths about Jaime and Cersei was a true treat, and it gave us some real insight into the depth of his delusions. Jaime Lannister is a man of action who has become completely stuck. He believes his love for his sister means he must stay with her—until death do they part—no matter what she’s done. That’s all he’s ever known of “love”—a toxic kind of codependency that has him convincing himself that she’s going to bring peace and all will be well soon. But once Olenna reminded him that he could be honest with her because she was never going to reveal his secrets, he showed in small ways that he was finally being more honest with himself, too. The completely flat way Coster-Waldau delivered his line about Jaime knowing Cersei will be the end of him showed how much he’s given up even thinking about who he could be without her. And the flash of anger that sprang to the surface when Olenna told him he’d regret spreading the “disease” of Cersei was a very interesting tell; Jaime wants to live in a make-believe world where Cersei is going to bring peace, and if he can’t convince himself of that, then everything could fall apart inside of him. There’s an emptiness to Jaime right now that’s tragic to see from such a formerly lively and impassioned character—almost as if the more powerful Cersei gets, the more he loses his sense of self. But there is still some honor in him, telling Olenna that he didn’t want her to die a painful death, despite what Cersei preferred.
Instead, Olenna was painlessly poisoned, which provided the perfect parallel for her to exploit in her final moments. Yes, it was fun to watch her pick apart Jaime and Cersei’s relationship and to call Joffrey what he truly was. But the best part of the entire scene was her slow, detailed description of Joffrey’s death to Jaime—preying on his helplessness in the moment of his son’s death before dropping the mic and finally saying the words out loud: “Tell Cersei. I want her to know it was me.”
Even in her own death scene, Olenna ended up with the upper hand. She played her last card at exactly the right moment, and Rigg gave that moment all the gravitas it deserved. This show is all about power, and Olenna died making a true power play. She never begged for her life or asked for forgiveness. She owned her crimes and admitted to never losing sleep over them. And she confessed to perhaps her biggest crime with a twinkle in her eye and an unwavering voice.
If you’re going to die on this show, that’s the kind of death scene you hope you get. And it was the kind of death scene a legend like Rigg deserved.
Honorable Mentions: “This is Jon Snow…He’s King in the North,” Jon and Tyrion reunite, Sansa proves herself to be a smart ruler of Winterfell, Tyrion narrates the attack on Casterly Rock, Cersei taunts Ellaria
I love your analysis of Jamie in this scene. It really was a great way to end the episode. This scene wasnt really about the revelation itself…at this point it doesn’t really matter who killed Joffery…but it did allow for a great scene between two great characters. A satisfying ending for one, and I hope what will be the start of a new story trajectory for the other.
In an episode with some pretty huge moments (I think the bromance tween Jon and Tyrion is my favorite relationship on the whole show), I am going to pick one of the more understated moments – the scene between Sam and Jorah. Sam as a character and his storyline in general has never been one of my favorites, but I absolutely love his story so far this season. He embodies the idea that there are more than one way to fight. And on a show where everything seems to be solved with death – killing your enemies, getting revenge – I love that we have Sam out there fighting for life – whether it be Jorah’s from dragonscale, or the entire human race from the threat of the whitewalkers. I loved the moment where he shakes Jorah’s hand, and Jorah grabs on with both hands, his first human contact in who knows how long. Jorah was facing insurmountably odds, and Sam was victorious – something that makes me hopeful for the upcoming fight against the whitewalkers. I cant wait to see what comes of Sam’s “punishment” of transcribing the oldest most neglected books of the citadel. Sam is pretty much the geek of Westeros, and I always love when the geek gets to shine.
Next week is supposedly half a battle scene, which is a total bummer. I know the show thinks its battles are their bread and butter, but I would trade 5 minutes of battle for 1 minute of any of these characters having a convo with each other any day.
Birthday girl, check the nerdygirl gmail.
THANK YOU SO MUCH! You are far too good to me, Tempest! Forever the Rose to my Peggy. ❤